Your Pie builds its menu around customizable pizzas, pastas, and salads rather than set combinations

Your Pie is a fast-casual pizza chain where you choose your crust, sauce, cheese, and toppings at the counter or through their online ordering system. Unlike traditional pizza restaurants with a fixed menu, Your Pie operates on a build-your-own model — you pay a base price for the crust size and type, then add toppings individually. The chain has locations across multiple states, though the number and locations change over time.

The ordering process is straightforward: you select your crust (typically hand-tossed, thin crust, or cauliflower crust options), choose a sauce, decide on cheese amount, and add vegetables, meats, or both. Prices vary by location and what you choose, so the final cost depends on your selections rather than a preset menu price. Your Pie also offers pasta bowls and salads built the same way.

The chain positions itself as faster than a traditional pizzeria but with more customization than a chain with a fixed menu. Most locations have dine-in seating, takeout, and delivery through their website or third-party apps. Hours and specific menu options vary by location.

Key Takeaways

  • Your Pie charges a base price for crust size and type, then adds individual topping costs, so your final price depends on what you choose.
  • You build pizzas, pastas, and salads at the counter by selecting from available crusts, sauces, cheeses, and toppings in real time.
  • The chain operates in multiple states but locations are not nationwide, so availability depends on your area.
  • Dine-in, takeout, and delivery are available at most locations, though hours and delivery coverage vary by restaurant.

How pricing works when you build your own

Your Pie's pricing structure is different from restaurants with a fixed menu because you pay for what you add. A small pizza starts at a base price that covers the crust and sauce, then each topping — whether vegetable or meat — costs extra. Large pizzas and specialty crusts (like cauliflower) have higher base prices. The exact topping cost varies by location and can range from under a dollar to a few dollars per item depending on the ingredient.

This means two people ordering the same size crust can end up paying very different amounts. Someone ordering a cheese pizza with two vegetables will pay less than someone adding five toppings and multiple meats. Your Pie's website or app for your specific location will show the base price and topping costs before you order, so you can see the total before checkout.

Specialty items like pasta bowls and salads follow the same model — you choose a base and add ingredients. Drinks, sides, and desserts are typically priced separately and are not customizable in the same way.

Crust and sauce options across locations

Most Your Pie locations offer at least three crust types: a hand-tossed crust (the standard option), a thin crust, and a cauliflower crust for lower-carb preferences. Some locations may have additional options like a gluten-free crust, but this varies. The crust you choose affects the base price — thin crust is usually the same as hand-tossed, while cauliflower or specialty crusts cost more.

Sauce choices typically include red marinara, white (alfredo or cream-based), and sometimes pesto or other specialty sauces. You can usually request no sauce or ask for a light or heavy amount. Sauce is included in the base price, so switching between available sauces does not change what you pay.

Because menu details vary by location, the best way to see what your nearest Your Pie offers is to check their website, call the restaurant directly, or look at their online ordering page. This shows exactly what crusts and sauces are available where you plan to order.

Topping choices and how they affect your total

Your Pie's topping list typically includes common vegetables (mushrooms, onions, peppers, tomatoes, spinach, olives), meats (pepperoni, sausage, bacon, ham), and sometimes specialty items like feta cheese or sun-dried tomatoes. Each topping is priced individually, and you can add as many or as few as you want. Meat toppings usually cost more than vegetable toppings.

The chain also offers cheese options — you can choose the amount of regular mozzarella, add extra cheese, or substitute other cheeses depending on what the location stocks. Some locations may charge extra for cheese changes, while others include it in the base price.

Since you see the price of each topping before you order, you can decide whether to add it based on cost. This transparency means you control exactly how much you spend and what goes on your pizza.

Ordering online versus in person

Your Pie's website and mobile app let you build your pizza online and pick it up or have it delivered. The online ordering process mirrors what you do in the restaurant — you select crust, sauce, cheese, and toppings, and the system shows your running total. You can save favorite orders for faster reordering next time.

In-person ordering at the counter is also straightforward: you walk up, tell the staff what you want, watch them build it, and pay. Some locations have a line during peak hours (lunch and dinner), so timing matters if you want to avoid waiting.

Delivery is available through Your Pie's website at most locations, though some areas may also use third-party delivery apps. Delivery fees and minimum order amounts vary by location and app. Takeout is usually ready within 10 to 20 minutes depending on how busy the restaurant is.

Dietary preferences and restrictions

Your Pie's customization model makes it relatively straightforward to build pizzas for common dietary preferences. You can order vegetarian by choosing only vegetable toppings, or vegan by requesting no cheese and using vegetable toppings only (though you should confirm the restaurant can accommodate this). Gluten-free crust is available at some locations, though not all — check with your specific restaurant before ordering.

If you have allergies or need to avoid specific ingredients, call the location directly rather than ordering online. Staff can tell you which toppings contain allergens and whether they can prevent cross-contact during preparation. Online ordering does not always capture allergy information clearly, so a phone call is safer.

Your Pie does not appear to have a dedicated allergen menu published online, so you will need to ask the restaurant about specific concerns. This is standard for customizable restaurants where ingredients can vary by location.

Location availability and how to find your nearest Your Pie

Your Pie operates in multiple states but is not a nationwide chain with locations everywhere. The number of restaurants and which states they operate in can change as the company opens or closes locations. To learn about there is a Your Pie near you, use the location finder on their official website — this shows current restaurants, hours, and whether they offer delivery.

If you find a location, you can also call them directly to ask about current hours, whether they are doing dine-in or takeout only, and what their typical wait times are. Some locations may have different hours on weekends or may close for renovations.

Your Pie's website also shows which third-party delivery apps service each location, so you can see whether DoorDash, Uber Eats, or other services are available in your area.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I order Your Pie through food delivery apps?

Yes, most Your Pie locations are available on third-party delivery apps like DoorDash and Uber Eats, though which apps service your location varies. You can also order directly through Your Pie's website for delivery or takeout. Check the location finder on their website to see which delivery options are available near you.

What happens if I do not like my pizza after I order it?

Return policies vary by location. Some restaurants will remake a pizza if something is wrong with it, while others may offer a refund or credit. Call the location where you ordered to discuss the issue — most will work with you if the pizza does not meet your expectations.

Do I have to pay extra for extra cheese or light cheese?

This depends on the location. Some Your Pie restaurants include standard cheese in the base price and charge extra for additional cheese, while others may not charge for adjusting the amount. Check the pricing on your location's online ordering page or ask when you order in person.

Is Your Pie cheaper than other pizza chains?

Cost depends on what you order and which chain you compare it to. Your Pie's build-your-own model means you pay only for what you add, so a straightforward cheese pizza may be cheaper than a preset menu pizza, but a heavily topped pizza could cost more. Compare prices at your local Your Pie and other chains in your area to see which fits your budget.

Can I modify my order after I place it online?

This depends on how far along your order is. If you order online and the restaurant has not started making it yet, call the location when ready to request changes. Once they begin preparing your pizza, changes become harder. For time-sensitive modifications, calling ahead is faster than trying to change it through the app.